If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Splenda and maltodextrin
Hi
I've been looking into the Glycemic Index of foods and found it odd that Splenda uses maltodextrin (GI=105) as a filler to bulk up their sucralose. Is that appropriate? Are it's effects on blood sugar insignificant due to the low density of the solid material which would mean a low Glycemic Load? Or do I have this all wrong? Kurt |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Splenda and maltodextrin
"Kurt" wrote in message
news Hi I've been looking into the Glycemic Index of foods and found it odd that Splenda uses maltodextrin (GI=105) as a filler to bulk up their sucralose. Is that appropriate? Generally speaking, no. But all powder forms of AS that use 1 to 1 spooning ratios use maltodextrin-- the packets use a different less bulky filler to get 2 tsp in one packet, but still comes out to .5 per tsp. Other AS's have liquid non carby versions of themselves, but not splenda. We've been trying to get the manufacturers of Splenda to change their "no liquid Splenda in the US" policy for some time. Care to join us in the effort? http://www.PetitionOnline.com/Splenda1/petition.html Are it's effects on blood sugar insignificant due to the low density of the solid material which would mean a low Glycemic Load? Or do I have this all wrong? For most people, i.e. non-diabetics, it would be a small amount, considering 1 tsp. of splenda is .5 gram while sugar is 4g per, but you still have to watch how much you consume-- splenda is not a free food if you are using the boxed powder or packets. Manufacturers, on the other hand, get to use the liquid splenda, which has no fillers, therefore no carbs. revek |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Splenda and maltodextrin
thanks, I just signed......
-- April Blues was 197/gained from 144-now163 /next goal 140 Started Low Carb on Jan 18th, 2001 www.candle.safewebshop.com "revek" wrote in message news:blh8ds$btvn8 Generally speaking, no. But all powder forms of AS that use 1 to 1 spooning ratios use maltodextrin-- the packets use a different less bulky filler to get 2 tsp in one packet, but still comes out to .5 per tsp. Other AS's have liquid non carby versions of themselves, but not splenda. We've been trying to get the manufacturers of Splenda to change their "no liquid Splenda in the US" policy for some time. Care to join us in the effort? http://www.PetitionOnline.com/Splenda1/petition.html ----------------------------------------------------------------------- Are it's effects on blood sugar insignificant due to the low density of the solid material which would mean a low Glycemic Load? Or do I have this all wrong? |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Splenda and maltodextrin
why do they have a no liquid splenda in the us thing ?
Chris Taylor http://www.nerys.com/ "revek" wrote in message ... "Kurt" wrote in message news Hi I've been looking into the Glycemic Index of foods and found it odd that Splenda uses maltodextrin (GI=105) as a filler to bulk up their sucralose. Is that appropriate? Generally speaking, no. But all powder forms of AS that use 1 to 1 spooning ratios use maltodextrin-- the packets use a different less bulky filler to get 2 tsp in one packet, but still comes out to .5 per tsp. Other AS's have liquid non carby versions of themselves, but not splenda. We've been trying to get the manufacturers of Splenda to change their "no liquid Splenda in the US" policy for some time. Care to join us in the effort? http://www.PetitionOnline.com/Splenda1/petition.html Are it's effects on blood sugar insignificant due to the low density of the solid material which would mean a low Glycemic Load? Or do I have this all wrong? For most people, i.e. non-diabetics, it would be a small amount, considering 1 tsp. of splenda is .5 gram while sugar is 4g per, but you still have to watch how much you consume-- splenda is not a free food if you are using the boxed powder or packets. Manufacturers, on the other hand, get to use the liquid splenda, which has no fillers, therefore no carbs. revek |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Splenda and maltodextrin
Chris Taylor Jr wrote:
why do they have a no liquid splenda in the us ? Because other liquid sweeteners never picked up much of the US market. They believe consumers prefer the convenience of packets for portability and the bulk that measures like sugar. LC is still a subset of the weight-conscious and diabetic population, most of which are not concerned by the 24g carb in a cup of Splenda, vs the 200 or so grams carb in equivalent sugar. If the carbs in Splenda are causing you a hardship, you're probably either eating too much sweet stuff or unnecessarily staying at induction level when most people can eat 10 to 40 more grams carb and still lose. -- jamie ) "There's a seeker born every minute." |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Splenda and maltodextrin
I still do not understand.
I read somewhere that one vendor was ordered to STOP selling liquid splenda. I can understand splenda not marketing here if it is not worth it to them but WHY stop or "ORDER" another vendor from offering yor liquid product (its not like they are copying it or something is it) in the us ? I want it to make water palatable. I simply can not easily drink the amout of water I need. I currently drink a minimum of just over 100 oz of best selection splenda sweetended sparkling water. (store bought so it is not packet sweetened) No artificial flavors or colors and no caffeine Chris Taylor http://www.nerys.com/ "jamie" wrote in message ... Chris Taylor Jr wrote: why do they have a no liquid splenda in the us ? Because other liquid sweeteners never picked up much of the US market. They believe consumers prefer the convenience of packets for portability and the bulk that measures like sugar. LC is still a subset of the weight-conscious and diabetic population, most of which are not concerned by the 24g carb in a cup of Splenda, vs the 200 or so grams carb in equivalent sugar. If the carbs in Splenda are causing you a hardship, you're probably either eating too much sweet stuff or unnecessarily staying at induction level when most people can eat 10 to 40 more grams carb and still lose. -- jamie ) "There's a seeker born every minute." |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Splenda and maltodextrin
It is a puzzlement why they think and behave the way they do. We lowcarbers
think it's a stupid policy. Unfortunately they hold all the cards but one, and that one is green. revek "Chris Taylor Jr" wrote in message ... I still do not understand. I read somewhere that one vendor was ordered to STOP selling liquid splenda. I can understand splenda not marketing here if it is not worth it to them but WHY stop or "ORDER" another vendor from offering yor liquid product (its not like they are copying it or something is it) in the us ? I want it to make water palatable. I simply can not easily drink the amout of water I need. I currently drink a minimum of just over 100 oz of best selection splenda sweetended sparkling water. (store bought so it is not packet sweetened) No artificial flavors or colors and no caffeine Chris Taylor http://www.nerys.com/ "jamie" wrote in message ... Chris Taylor Jr wrote: why do they have a no liquid splenda in the us ? Because other liquid sweeteners never picked up much of the US market. They believe consumers prefer the convenience of packets for portability and the bulk that measures like sugar. LC is still a subset of the weight-conscious and diabetic population, most of which are not concerned by the 24g carb in a cup of Splenda, vs the 200 or so grams carb in equivalent sugar. If the carbs in Splenda are causing you a hardship, you're probably either eating too much sweet stuff or unnecessarily staying at induction level when most people can eat 10 to 40 more grams carb and still lose. -- jamie ) "There's a seeker born every minute." |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Splenda and maltodextrin
green card ??? That one missed me ?
Chris Taylor http://www.nerys.com/ "revek" wrote in message ... It is a puzzlement why they think and behave the way they do. We lowcarbers think it's a stupid policy. Unfortunately they hold all the cards but one, and that one is green. revek "Chris Taylor Jr" wrote in message ... I still do not understand. I read somewhere that one vendor was ordered to STOP selling liquid splenda. I can understand splenda not marketing here if it is not worth it to them but WHY stop or "ORDER" another vendor from offering yor liquid product (its not like they are copying it or something is it) in the us ? I want it to make water palatable. I simply can not easily drink the amout of water I need. I currently drink a minimum of just over 100 oz of best selection splenda sweetended sparkling water. (store bought so it is not packet sweetened) No artificial flavors or colors and no caffeine Chris Taylor http://www.nerys.com/ "jamie" wrote in message ... Chris Taylor Jr wrote: why do they have a no liquid splenda in the us ? Because other liquid sweeteners never picked up much of the US market. They believe consumers prefer the convenience of packets for portability and the bulk that measures like sugar. LC is still a subset of the weight-conscious and diabetic population, most of which are not concerned by the 24g carb in a cup of Splenda, vs the 200 or so grams carb in equivalent sugar. If the carbs in Splenda are causing you a hardship, you're probably either eating too much sweet stuff or unnecessarily staying at induction level when most people can eat 10 to 40 more grams carb and still lose. -- jamie ) "There's a seeker born every minute." |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Splenda and maltodextrin
Chris Taylor Jr wrote:
I still do not understand. I read somewhere that one vendor was ordered to STOP selling liquid splenda. I can understand splenda not marketing here if it is not worth it to them but WHY stop or "ORDER" another vendor from offering yor liquid product (its not like they are copying it or something is it) in the us ? Legally, it is pretty much like they were copying it. A US webstore was selling Brazilian liquid Splenda. MacNeil, who has the exclusive distribution rights for Splenda in the US, apparently got wind of it and stopped it, because the store had no right to sell non-MacNeil Splenda *in* the US. No doubt the Brazilian manufacturer still sells it, but you'd have to find a foreign vendor to buy it from. -- jamie ) "There's a seeker born every minute." |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Splenda and maltodextrin
ahhh I see lawyer crap.
so basically they were both selling SPLENDA but only one person was "licensed" to legally do so in the US by splenda ? That makes much more sense. Typical lawyer crap. Chris Taylor http://www.nerys.com/ "jamie" wrote in message ... Chris Taylor Jr wrote: I still do not understand. I read somewhere that one vendor was ordered to STOP selling liquid splenda. I can understand splenda not marketing here if it is not worth it to them but WHY stop or "ORDER" another vendor from offering yor liquid product (its not like they are copying it or something is it) in the us ? Legally, it is pretty much like they were copying it. A US webstore was selling Brazilian liquid Splenda. MacNeil, who has the exclusive distribution rights for Splenda in the US, apparently got wind of it and stopped it, because the store had no right to sell non-MacNeil Splenda *in* the US. No doubt the Brazilian manufacturer still sells it, but you'd have to find a foreign vendor to buy it from. -- jamie ) "There's a seeker born every minute." |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Splenda Tablets | hba1c | General Discussion | 7 | March 30th, 2004 04:09 AM |
Splenda tablets - Why can't Johnson & Johnson sell them in the US? | hba1c | General Discussion | 79 | March 24th, 2004 06:38 PM |